Try our free symptom checker
Get a thorough self-assessment before your visit to the doctor.
Olive oil is one of the most commonly used oils in most kitchens across the globe especially in Italy. Because of this, it is a staple in recipes ranging from salad dressings to sautéing vegetables. The following are some of the key factors when it comes to the most superior Italian olive oil.
Before we get started, it is important to understand that not all olive oils are the same. The best type of olive oil is the extra-virgin one which comes from pure and unrefined olives that are cold-pressed. It is also an expensive one. Virgin olive oil is also made from pure, cold-pressed olives, but it is less acidic than extra virgin olive oil and has less flavor. Last but not the least is the refined olive oil which is a combination of cold pressed and chemically extracted olive oils. It has a very bland taste and should, therefore, be used for roasting, grilling, and baking.
Top 3 Best Italian Olive Oils
- Frantoi Cutrera Primo Cold Extracted Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil
- Barbera Frantoia Extra Virgin Olive Oil
- AmazonFresh Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Below are the best Italian olive oils that you should definitely stock in your kitchen. Italian olive oils are some of the best in the international market and we have tried a number of brands to give you our best recommendation. Be it a sharp and pungent oil for dressing grilled vegetables or a light and creamy oil for your best-loved salad, this article has you sorted. Below are our best picks of the Italian olive oils that you can purchase in the current market.
If you are interested in purchasing a top-quality Italian olive oil, Barbera Frantoia Extra Virgin Olive Oil comes highly recommended.
Pros
- Best by Mar 2024
- Product of Italy
- Kosher
Cons
- Not the cheapest option
- Some may find it too fruity
- Not suitable for high-heat cooking
Recently we have been trying Barbera Frantoia Extra Virgin Olive Oil and it is quite satisfactory in quality. This oil has a fruity taste, which makes it suitable for use in salads or dipping bread. It is also unaltered and done without adding heat, thus preserving the true quality of the tea.
We also like the fact that this is an Italian product and that it is olive oil. This olive oil comes from a country where it was produced, and that is always good news when you are making a purchase. It is also kosher, so it can suit the needs of people who adhere to kosher requirements.
At the same time, we would like to mention that using this olive oil is going to cost you more than using other similar products. We must admit that it costs slightly more than other services, but we think that it is worthy of the price. However, there might be complaints about the overemphasis on the fruity taste and the general taste being too strong. Last but not least, this particular olive oil is not for cooking and should be reserved for salads that are served cold.
All in all, we are proposing Barbera Frantoia Extra Virgin Olive Oil to anyone who is in search of an Italian olive oil. With a fresh fruit taste, its Italian roots, and kosher accreditation, it is a perfect addition to any kitchen.
If you are interested in buying a tasty olive oil that has a strong smell and taste, then you should go for the Italian Polyphenol Rich Olive Oil Extra Virgin.
Pros
- Supercharge with One Shot - Gourmet Extra Virgin Olive Oil - We Recommend Using Virgeen Raw to Fully Appreciate All Natural Oleocanthal and Polyphenol Proprieties- Taste One Daily Tablespoon, Drizzle It On Your Fresh Salad, Dip Your Favorite Bread
- Awarded Winning Taste and Aroma - High Olive Polyphenols and Oleocanthal Content Lab Reports Inside Every Box (+420,7mg/kg) - Polyphenol Rich Olive Oil - Recreate Natural Chefs Recipes With Virgeen Pure Olive Oil From Italy Rich In Polyphenols
- Premium Fresh Single Source Quality - Hand Harvest Olive Oil Trees - Cold pressed Within 4 Hours To Lock-in all Powerful Phenolic Proprieties - Small Family Farm Limited Edition Polyphenol Rich Olive Oil - Only 3800 Liters/year EVOO Extra Virgin Olive Oil - Additive Free
Cons
- Expensive compared to other olive oils.
- May not be suitable for those with a sensitive palate.
- May not be readily available in all stores.
I was happy with the deep flavor and smell of this olive oil that is best used in salad dressings, bread dipping, and adding to your meals. Due to its high olive polyphenols and oleocanthal, this is a healthy option and we appreciated the fact that this olive oil is cold pressed within 4 hours of harvesting to preserve all the phenolic qualities.
Among the things that we liked in this particular olive oil is that it is a first cold-pressed, single-estate, hand-picked olive oil derived from olive trees and made from a small family-owned farm in Italy. It helps in ensuring that you are receiving the best product that is free from additives and prepared with much attention.
Some may consider the price of this olive oil to be rather high compared to the other products available out there; however, the exquisite flavor and the healthy properties of this product make it worth the money. It is not recommended for those who have a sensitive taste bud as it may not be easily accessible in all supermarkets.
We strongly recommend you buy AmazonFresh Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil because of its palatable taste with an undertone of pepper and herbs.
Pros
- Cold extracted
- Great for cooking, grilling, and in finishing dishes
- Pressed and bottled in Italy
Cons
- Not the best choice for those who prefer a stronger olive taste
- The plastic bottle may not be as durable as a glass one
- The flavor may vary slightly from bottle to bottle
I found this olive oil suitable for those who prefer minimal interference with the taste of the foods they are preparing. It is perfect for sautéing and deep-frying and ideal for dunking, emulsifying when making dressing or marinades and as a final garnish. If you enjoyed La Tourangelle, Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil we recommend AmazonFresh Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil.
As far as our experience is concerned, this olive oil has good stability at high temperatures and contributes a great taste to the food items for which it has been used. We love that it is cold extracted and pressed and comes in a bottle from Italy. However, for anyone who wants olive flavor to be more dominant, there are better options in the market. Furthermore, the plastic bottle may not be as strong as a glass one, and the taste may not be the same in another bottle.
Altogether, we recommend you try AmazonFresh Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil. It’s inexpensive and gives dishes a slightly creamy texture that’s not overpowering.
We encourage you to use Laudemio Tuscany Extra Virgin Olive Oil because of its quality and genuine flavor of Tuscany.
Pros
- Imported from Italy
- Strict standards for planting, harvesting, and extraction
- Authentic Tuscan flavor
Cons
- Higher price point
- May be too strong for some palates
- Limited availability in some areas
Laudemio Tuscany Extra Virgin Olive Oil is sourced directly from the origin in Italy and is made from high standards of planting, harvesting, and milking. This leads to an incredible quality oil with an original Tuscan taste that is ideal for marinating salads, pasta dishes, and much more.
The most exceptional aspect of Laudemio Tuscany Extra Virgin Olive Oil is that the entire process has been carried out maintaining very high standards. Even from the time the trees are planted to the time the oil is squeezed out of the fruit, each process is controlled and refined to produce the best product.
However, the con of higher price is counter balanced by the superior quality and delicious flavor of Laudemio Tuscany Extra Virgin Olive Oil. However, those people who are very picky with the food that they eat may find the taste of pastrami to be strong.
In conclusion, we fully endorse Laudemio Tuscany Extra Virgin Olive Oil for those who are in search of exquisite Tuscan olive oil.
If you are interested in purchasing an Italian olive oil, Papa Vince Olive Oil Extra Virgin would be a perfect choice.
Pros
- Made from organic olives locally grown by our family in Sicily
- High in polyphenols and vitamins
- Delightful flavor that goes a long way
Cons
- Expensive compared to other brands
- Some may not like the peppery finish
- Glass bottle may not be ideal for travel
Ever since we started using this product, specifically the Papa Vince Olive Oil Extra Virgin, we have been hooked. That it is made from organic olives locally sourced from Sicily by the family is a plus for us. We acknowledge that it has no pesticides, additives, coloring, insecticides, or herbicides in it.
Another thing that we like about this olive oil is that it contains polyphenols and vitamins. At the time of bottling, it had 420 mg/kg of polyphenols, which in turn assists in counteracting free radicals. It also contains vitamin E and K as indicated in the nutrition facts panel.
The taste of this olive oil is very nice, and a little goes a long way. It has a fresh green light texture that will make all your dishes appear new again. The fine peppery feeling felt at the back of the throat is an indication of high polyphenol levels. We prefer using it for sprinkling over salads, dressings, pasta, meat, vegetables, dips, soups, marinades, and bread, among others. It can turn your meals in the blink of an eye and enhance the sautéed vegetables, fried eggs, or grilled fish.
This olive oil has one drawback, though it is rather significant; it is considerably more costly than other olive oils. A few people may not enjoy the strong black pepper kick at the end, which we appreciate. The glass bottle does not appear to be portable but is effective for maintaining the quality of the oil.
In summary, we do endorse the Papa Vince Olive Oil Extra Virgin for anyone who wants to get an outstanding Italian organic olive oil that includes polyphenols and has a fantastic taste.
We suggest Frantoia Extra Virgin Olive Oil if people want to consume real Italian quality extra virgin olive oil.
Pros
- Its fruity, sweet flavor with a hint of almond and spicy aroma is a delight for the taste buds and a treat for the senses.
- The oil is hand-harvested and continuously extracted, separated by centrifuge, allowing the oil to settle and then decanted naturally without being filtered.
- Frantoia Extra Virgin Olive Oil is obtained from cold pressing the best quality Sicilian olives: Biancolilla, Nocellara del Belice, Cerasuola - originating in the surrounding hillsides of West-Central Sicily.
Cons
- Frantoia Extra Virgin Olive Oil from Italy is quite expensive compared to other olive oils.
- The tin it comes in is not very easy to store.
- It may not be readily available in all stores.
Frantoia extra virgin olive oil from Italy is ideal for seafood, fresh cheeses, vegetable soup, and all forms of mixed salads. It is also perfect for dipping bread or for use as a dressing for pasta, grilled vegetables, and grilled meats. Its fruity note improves the dishes and is vital for those who respect the natural, qualitative ingredients.
This particular type of Italian olive oil, Frantoia Extra Virgin Olive Oil, is cold-pressed and unfiltered. It also contains fats that are healthy for the heart and antioxidants that are essential in the body. It has a quality taste and authentic flavor, hence making it worthy of spending money on.
The ROI Ligurian Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil is highly recommended for anyone who is seeking an olive oil that can be used daily.
Pros
- Made from Italian Olives only, resulting in an everyday gourmet olive oil.
- Milling the olives within 24 hr of picking or less, results in a high quality olive oil with high Polyphenols content (antioxidants) you can taste, and Low Acidity levels.
- Low acidity olive oil with a golden green color, a light fruity aroma, and a sweet sensation which enhances the characteristics of foods without being intrusive.
Cons
- A little expensive for everyday use.
- The bottle is a bit bulky.
- Some people may find the taste too mild.
We were particularly impressed with this all-natural production process of this olive oil. The olives are milled within 24 hours of picking therefore produces olive oil with high polyphenols as well as low acidity levels. This is a fine extra virgin olive oil from Italy suitable for all recipes, sauces and marinades requiring it.
This all-round olive oil also works well in finishing off meals and as a dip for bread. What we especially like is the fact it is a great all round ingredient in any Italian kitchen.
The ROI family has been producing Italian olive oil since the beginning of the twentieth century and they focus on taggiasca olive trees cultivation. This is a natural Olive Oil that is produced in Liguria, Italy, by the use of quality materials that are sourced. The estate is in one of the most special parts of Italy, and the olive trees are cultivated on very steep slopes of hills and coastal cliffs with stunning views of the Mediterranean Sea. According to Jake, the wonderful taste and a very special aroma of the oil originate from the climate and sea.
All in all, we really recommend the ROI Ligurian Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil as a high-quality product suitable for anyone who enjoys Italian cuisine. It is also perfect as a gift when combined with other products from the ROI family. We strongly recommend the proposed product to every home cook who dreams about having the perfect Italian meal at home.
If you are interested in purchasing a high quality divine Italian olive oil that can be used to enhance the taste of dishes, then you should consider using Frantoi Cutrera Primo Cold Extracted Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil.
Pros
- The notes of balsamic herbs and sweet almond make it a unique and flavorful addition to any dish.
- It is cold extracted and organically farmed, ensuring that you get the purest and freshest olive oil possible.
- It is versatile and can be used in a variety of dishes, from roasted meat and fish to salads and minestrone soup.
Cons
- It is quite expensive compared to other olive oils on the market.
- The taste may be too strong for some people.
- The packaging is not very user-friendly.
From our experience, Frantoi Cutrera Primo Olive Oil could be recommended for anyone who wishes to give his or her dish an Italian feel. The notes of balsamic herbs and sweet almonds make it tasteful to add to any dish, and the cold extraction makes it possible to get the purest and freshest olive oil.
We concluded that it is very useful and can be added to practically any dish, including roast meat or fish, as well as salads or minestrone soup. But it is relatively pricey than other olive oil brands available in the market and the taste is a little overpowering. Also, the packaging is not very convenient for consumers, which may cause difficulties in pouring the oil.
In conclusion, we would advise anyone who is interested in purchasing a superior quality Italian olive oil to go for the Frantoi Cutrera Primo Olive Oil.
Buying Guide
There are some factors that should be put into consideration while selecting the best Italian olive oil. Here are some features to look for:
Olive Varieties
Extra virgin Italian olive oil is produced from different types of olives, all of which have distinct flavors and fragrances. Some of the widely cultivated Italian olive types are Frantoio, Leccino, and Pendolino among others. To decide what kind of olive oil taste you prefer, it may be useful to try different olive oils produced from different varieties.
Quality
The quality of Italian olive oil depends on the features such as the level of acidity, the time of production, and the extent of refining. Minimally acidic olive oils should also be considered as these are some of the best quality olive oils. Cleanliness is also very important because olive oil deteriorates with time and can become rancid. One should look at the date on which the oil was harvested to ensure that it is still fresh. Lastly, it is advised to look for the term ‘pure olive oil’ as some manufacturers add other cheaper types of oil to the bottle.
Certification
Another criterion when it comes to Italian olive oil is certification. You should try to look for DOP (Protected Designation of Origin) or IGP (Protected Geographical Indication) logos because they signify that the oil has been made in a given area using traditional techniques.
Packaging
The type of container used to package Italian olive oil also determines the quality and taste of the oil. Search for bottles with the dark glass as this guards the oil from light and high temperature and make sure that the bottle is correctly sealed to avoid oxidation.
With these factors in mind, you will be able to make the right decision when selecting an Italian olive oil.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are some trusted brands for Italian olive oil?
Some of the most popular brands of extra virgin olive oil include Frantoia, Laudemio, and Olio Carli.
What makes the extra virgin olive oil the best for our hearts?
Extra virgin olive oil is the most advisable because it is made from open-pulped olives without use of any chemical or solvent. It also contains monounsaturated fats which are beneficial in lowering cholesterol and preventing heart related complications.
Which brand is better for Italian olive oil, Bertolli or Colavita?
It is noteworthy that Bertolli and Colavita are famous brands of Italian olive oil, and therefore, the choice between them is a matter of taste. Colavita has a milder taste compared to Bertolli which is a little strong but at the same time very tasty.
Can you recommend a high-quality Greek olive oil?
Yes, Kalamata is among the leading brands of Greek olive oil. Their olive oil is made from selected olive fruits and has a fully fruity taste.
Which is the leading Italian food brand for olive oil?
The most recognizable Italian food brand of olive oil would probably be Filippo Berio. They sell different types of olive oils such as extra virgin olive oil, organic olive oil and even olive oils with a twist.
Affiliate Disclosure:
The links provided may earn us a small commission at no additional cost to you if you choose to purchase the recommended product. This support allows our research and editorial team to continue providing high-quality recommendations. As a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising initiative, we are able to earn advertising fees through providing links to products on Amazon.com. Please rest assured that we only recommend high-quality products.
Was this article helpful?